Solutions

Problem Set 3

MTHE / MATH 328 — Real Analysis · Winter 2026

Problem 1: Arzelà–Ascoli Subsequence

ProblemUniformly Convergent Subsequence via Arzela Ascoli

Let (fn)(f_n) be real-valued, twice continuously differentiable on [0,1][0,1], with fn(0)=fn(0)=0f_n(0) = f_n'(0) = 0 and sup[0,1]fn2\sup_{[0,1]} |f_n''| \leq 2. Prove some subsequence converges uniformly.

Problem 2: GδG_\delta Sets

ProblemG-delta Sets in R

Show each is a GδG_\delta set:

(a) (0,2](0, 2].

(b) The set L\mathcal{L} of Liouville numbers.

(c) {x:f(x)=0}\{x : f'(x) = 0\} for a differentiable f:RRf : \mathbb{R} \to \mathbb{R}.

Problem 3: Reduction to Components

ProblemDifferentiability Reduces to Component Differentiability

If F=(F1,,Fm):URm\vec F = (F_1, \dots, F_m): U \to \mathbb{R}^m and each FjF_j is differentiable at a\vec a, show F\vec F is differentiable at a\vec a.

Problem 4: Continuity of Partials Implies Differentiability

ProblemContinuous Partials Implies Differentiability

Under the hypotheses of the theorem (partials exist near a\vec a and continuous at a\vec a), prove f:=Fjf := F_j is differentiable at a\vec a with Df(a)=f(a)Df(\vec a) = \nabla f(\vec a)^\top.

Problem 5: Implicit Function Theorem Application

ProblemImplicit Function Theorem — Curve Equation

Consider CC defined by

log ⁣(cos(y+π12)+sin(y+π12))log ⁣(cos(y+π12)sin(y+π12))=2x+log(2+3).\log\!\left(\cos(y + \tfrac{\pi}{12}) + \sin(y + \tfrac{\pi}{12})\right) - \log\!\left(\cos(y + \tfrac{\pi}{12}) - \sin(y + \tfrac{\pi}{12})\right) = 2x + \log(2 + \sqrt 3).

Show that near (0,π/12)(0, \pi/12), CC is the graph of a C1C^1 function y=g(x)y = g(x) satisfying g(x)=cos(2g(x)+π/6)g'(x) = \cos(2g(x) + \pi/6), g(0)=π/12g(0) = \pi/12.

Problem 6: Implicit Curve in R3\mathbb{R}^3

ProblemImplicit Curve in R3

Let f1=xy+z+yx+z+zx+y4f_1 = \tfrac{x}{y+z} + \tfrac{y}{x+z} + \tfrac{z}{x+y} - 4, f2=x2y+z+y2x+z+z2x+y42f_2 = \tfrac{x^2}{y+z} + \tfrac{y^2}{x+z} + \tfrac{z^2}{x+y} - 42. Let CC be where both vanish.

(a) Near (11,4,1)(11, 4, -1), represent CC as (g1(x),g2(x))(g_1(x), g_2(x)).

(b) Find tangent line at (11,4,1)(11, 4, -1).